My Honda Eu3000is is a little lighter than multiple marine deep cycle batteries and almost as quiet. It is a little more expensive initially, but I expect it to outlast marine deep cycle batteries while helping me burn down into stained water with my HPS's for years to come.
With that being said, I have two buddies with ten 50watt LED set-ups on their boats that I have fished over for many hours. I like them a lot and like running "stealth" with the radio option. Truth is, we play music when running my Honda too, so I am not sure that I am ready to go the direction that you're heading with this question just yet. I think that LED lights that burn down into stained water as effectively as HPS, yet film out white and can run all night efficiently on batteries will be possible in years to come. Ask me in a couple years as technology increases and I might have a different opinion. Years ago, I resisted change and didn't think CDs would replace audio cassette tapes originally either. Looking back, I attribute that to being tight with my wallet; maybe that factor drives my lighting choices too. I have a working option now, so no need to spend time and money to replace it just yet.
Good Luck!